New HMRC powers of discovery will be retrospective
The government has confirmed that the Finance Bill will include changes to discovery assessments, allowing HMRC to recoup unpaid high income child benefit charges going back almost ten years. What’s the full story?

The unpopular high-income child benefit charge (HICBC) was introduced in 2013. Despite HMRC administering child benefit payments, it is still finding taxpayers that have not declared the benefit in previous years. Once the Finance Bill is enacted, HMRC will be able to open discovery assessments to collect any unpaid tax charges from as far back as 2013. However, the change will not apply to those who have already appealed against such assessments.
This addition to the Finance Bill is a result of the Upper Tribunal decision in Wilkes v HMRC, which found that HMRC did not have the power to impose the HICBC by means of discovery assessment as there was no income which ought to have been assessed. As a result, Mr Wilkes did not have to pay the tax charges. Individuals with income over £50,000, where either they or their partner receives child benefit, could soon receive a large unexpected tax bill from several years ago.
Related Topics
-
Time off for fertility treatment?
A survey by Fertility Matters at Work has revealed that more than one-third of employees undergoing fertility treatment have resigned or are considering resigning because of the physical and emotional toll. Is there a right to time off for fertility treatment?
-
Was a company buyback of EIS shares tax avoidance?
Two taxpayers used the “purchase of own shares” procedure to extract gains they’d made from enterprise investment scheme (EIS) shares. HMRC said this was unfair tax avoidance, the taxpayers disagreed. What did the Upper Tribunal decide?
-
HMRC’s new compliance check service
HMRC has published a collection of videos and notes to help if you’re picked for a compliance check. Is HMRC’s new service worth a look or is it just official propaganda?